Originally reported on November 11, 2026.
In a November 8 post on X, Vitalik Buterin questioned whether ETH’s fee burns provide a reliable valuation floor. Ethereum’s “ultrasound money” narrative held that more activity would mean more fees burned, potentially offsetting new issuance. Buterin argued that much of the historically high fee revenue came from speculation within crypto—and could shrink when that activity subsides.
He still supported retaining EIP-1559. In his view, it would not be regrettable if burns remained below 10% of new issuance over the long term; pursuing higher fees merely to sustain burns could instead harm Ethereum’s decentralization and long-term development.
Supply mechanisms are not interchangeable
The original article compared seven networks to show why a falling burn figure does not mean the same thing for every token:
- BTC has a supply cap of roughly 21 million. At a 3.125 BTC block reward and an average ten-minute block time, the article estimated annual issuance at about 164,300 BTC, or 0.82% of supply.
- ETH had grown in supply by about 1.37% since the 2022 Merge. EIP-1559 burns base fees, but over the 30 days preceding the report, burns offset only about 3.2% of new issuance.
- SOL follows a declining inflation schedule: an initial annual rate of 8%, decreasing by 15% each year toward a long-term target of 1.5%. During the 2024 meme-token surge, daily burns at one point exceeded 10,000 SOL; in January 2025, burns offset about 23% of issuance. After SIMD-0096 directed all priority fees to validators while leaving 50% of base fees to be burned, daily burns at one point fell to about 700 SOL.
- BNB has no continuing issuance and reduces supply through quarterly Auto-Burn and BEP-95 fee burns, with a target supply of 100 million. The article reported that the first four quarterly burns of 2026 totaled about 6.2 million BNB.
- TRX is issued through block rewards, while users’ Energy and Bandwidth payments can be burned. Because users can also obtain resources by staking or renting them, more USDT transfers do not necessarily produce a matching increase in burns.
- AVAX has a 720 million supply cap, issues staking rewards and burns fees on its X, C and P chains. By early November 2026, the article put cumulative minting at about 474 million AVAX—including roughly 114 million in staking rewards—and cumulative burns at about 5.18 million.
- SUI has a fixed total supply of 10 billion. Its circulating supply rises chiefly through unlocks. Its Storage Fund locks some storage fees; fees not returned when data is deleted remain in the fund, reducing freely circulating supply rather than being permanently burned.
What a burn-based valuation misses
The article revisited a simple model Buterin discussed: divide the annual value of tokens burned by a discount rate. A steady $1 billion in annual burns at a 4% rate would imply $25 billion. The crucial assumption is steady burns.
According to the article, Ethereum burned about 1.48 million ETH, worth approximately $3.6 billion, in 2022. From the start of 2026 through November 8, it put burns at about 19,200 ETH, worth roughly $43 million. Annualizing that latter figure to about $50 million would yield a valuation of approximately $1.25 billion under the same model—more than 200 times below the roughly $270 billion ETH market capitalization cited for that period. This is an illustration of the model’s limits, not an alternative price target.
Burns also omit other ways network activity can distribute value: SOL priority fees flow to validators, while TRX resource rentals may generate income for stakers. Neither is fully reflected in token burns.
Buterin instead emphasized Ethereum’s decentralization, censorship resistance, open-source nature, privacy and security, suggesting that systems able to operate reliably without control by a single party may become more valuable as AI develops. The article also raised a constraint on that store-of-value argument: unlike BTC, ETH has no fixed supply cap, and its issuance rules can change through protocol upgrades. Whether demand for ETH as collateral, a medium of exchange and a native asset of financial infrastructure supports a durable monetary premium remains a question—not something a burn figure alone can settle.
Source: odaily.news (originally published 2026-11-11 20:30 UTC+8)




